DPC Covers the Everyday. What Covers the Catastrophe?

If you haven’t already felt sticker shock from health insurance premiums, odds are that you will this year. Between a loss of ACA subsidies and the rising cost of healthcare (not to mention ongoing profiteering from health insurance companies), Americans are expected to pay between 11-16% higher health insurance premiums in 2027—with increases of up to 40% in some states like my own in Florida.
For those of us in DPC, rising insurance costs reinforce the appeal of affordable, direct access to a physician. But they also leave patients asking an important question: What happens if I need hospitalization or receive a serious diagnosis? I’ve received numerous messages from patients—and fellow physicians—looking for options.
I know this struggle firsthand. Over ten years in direct care, I’ve exhausted my short-term insurance coverage, tried several health sharing organizations, and paid top dollar for a high-deductible PPO group plan I found through a broker. When that coverage abruptly ended this fall, I turned to Virtuous Benefits, an independent employee benefits agency that offers health plans incorporating DPC. It’s too early to report on my experience, but I’m glad to have found an option less expensive than the Marketplace plans available to me in my state.
As you counsel patients and consider your own options, here is what I’ve learned during my journey in trying to find catastrophic health insurance.
Short-term insurance (Non-ACA Compliant Plans)
Intended to bridge patients between jobs or during financial hardship, short-term insurance policies are far less expensive than anything you’ll find on the ACA Marketplace. While some critics refer to these products as ‘junk’ plans (because they have high deductibles, don’t cover pre-existing conditions or pay for preventive care), they can serve as an affordable option for people who are generally healthy and can afford to pay out-of-pocket for routine screening tests.
Initially restricted to 12 months, these plans may now be used for up to 36 months of coverage. You can buy a non-ACA compliant short-term plan directly from the major insurance carriers or use a broker. I maxed out my three-year term, and I’d still have this type of plan if it were allowed.
Fixed Indemnity Plans
Fixed indemnity policies pay a predetermined amount for a covered event or service—for example, a set payment for each day in the hospital. The payment is based on the policy’s benefit schedule, rather than your actual medical bill.
These policies are seriously cheap relative to traditional health insurance. The downside to indemnity plans is that they only reimburse a small portion of medical expenses and they cap out at a maximum of $50,000 to $500,000, depending on the plan. For example, one indemnity plan being advertised to DPC physicians shows a maximum benefit of $100,000 per calendar year.
I looked into this option, but for me, it didn’t make sense since I can afford to pay for minor health costs out-of-pocket. What I’m really looking for is something that will cover me in a true catastrophe–a hospital stay or serious diagnosis that could easily exceed $100,000 and overwhelm my finances. However, an indemnity plan might make sense for someone who is young and healthy or to offset costs associated with a high-deductible health plan.
Health Shares
Originally affiliated with faith-based organizations, health shares now include secular options. Members contribute money toward eligible medical expenses, and most health shares help negotiate bills.
While these plans are generally less expensive, they are not traditional insurance and are not subject to federal laws requiring coverage for pre-existing conditions or overall coverage. Reimbursement is not guaranteed (then again, after being dropped abruptly by one of the B.U.C.A.H.’s, I recognize that no insurance payment is a given).
Over the last decade I’ve tried out health sharing plans for myself and my office manager through Liberty and Medishare. The share cost is very low (relative to traditional insurance). While I can’t personally speak to reimbursement since I never had to ‘use’ my health share during the two years I contributed to it, I personally know several DPC physicians who report satisfaction with reimbursement, including for major expenses like surgery and cancer treatment.
Group Coverage for Self-employed Individuals
Two years ago, an insurance broker helped me find coverage marketed to self-employed individuals. It wasn’t cheap, but it cost less than my Marketplace options at the time. I purchased a high-deductible plan that allowed HSA contributions and felt reassured that I had protection against major expenses. It was also nice to get a “free” mammogram and shingles vaccine—even though their combined cash price was far less than one month’s premium.
Then came year two. The plan changed administrators, and I was double charged for several months. After months of a telephone runaround that would have made a perfect Dr. Glaucomflecken skit, I finally threatened to file a dispute with my credit card company. At that point I finally received a refund–not just for my double charges, but for all of premiums for the year, along with a note of cancellation of my policy. It turned out that it wasn’t just me—that plan dropped all of its members.
I’m not sure if these types of plans even exist anymore. My insurance broker, likely overwhelmed with other clients in the same boat, stopped returning my phone calls, and a Google search did not turn up any options.
However, if you have a business and are interested in covering employees as well as yourself, there are self-employment small business plans that may be worth considering:
Employee Group Plans
There are three ways to find employee coverage: Direct from an insurance company, through an association with a professional organization (like your state/ county/ specialty medical society), or through an independent benefits agency.
Eligibility and participation requirements vary; most arrangements require enrollment of both the physician and at least one eligible employee, and most require some degree of underwriting. I’ve reviewed plans offered through my county medical society, through a payroll services company, and ultimately chose an independent benefits agency.
I was able to purchase a high-deductible HSA insurance plan that includes DPC membership for my family and my staff member at a lower cost than my options on the exchange, although we did have to pass a basic underwriting evaluation. If you have at least one employee, it may be worth looking into employee group plans to cover yourself as well as for the business tax deduction.
ACA Marketplace plans
While premiums for ACA marketplace plans are only going up, they remain an important option for physicians with pre-existing conditions, high medical needs, or expensive brand-name medications. Open enrollment occurs annually, although job loss or change (like leaving your current job to open your direct care practice) qualifies for special enrollment. Keep in mind that selecting a health savings account (HAS) plan can be a helpful tax and investment strategy.
Spouse Coverage
In the absolutely atrocious movie I Now Pronounce You Chuck and Larry, two buddies fake a domestic partnership to get insurance benefits–proving that this problem goes back at least to 2007. While I’m not suggesting you fake a marriage, if your spouse has the opportunity to purchase family coverage through employer-sponsored insurance, this is an option worth looking at. In fact, on a recent Facebook thread on this topic, one physician said her husband was considering a part-time school bus driver position just for the insurance benefits.
Advocating for better options
DPC can meet a wide range of primary care needs, and direct specialty care can make additional services more accessible. However, neither eliminates the financial risk of a major illness or hospitalization.
That gap may also limit the growth of direct care. Patients who value DPC still need a workable way to pay for care beyond our offices. Access to affordable, reliable wrap-around coverage for major expenses would likely make direct care even more feasible for more families and employers.
My own experience with the high cost of health insurance has reinforced both the value of direct care and the importance of physician advocacy toward broader healthcare reform. I encourage all physicians (and patients) to urge our legislators to enact policies that both enhance direct care and make catastrophic coverage available to all.







This is great information. Thank you